Child Trauma & Behavioral Problems

Marcus, 8, referred by school

Presentation

Aggressive outbursts at school — hitting peers, throwing objects, defying teachers. Nightmares 3-4x/week. Wets the bed. Clings to mother at drop-off, then erupts within an hour. Teacher says: 'He goes from zero to sixty with no warning.' Mother says: 'He wasn't like this before.'

History

Witnessed domestic violence between parents ages 3-6. Father incarcerated when Marcus was 6. Mother working two jobs. Currently living with maternal grandmother. Grandmother is warm but overwhelmed. No prior therapy.

Clinical note: Marcus's aggression, nightmares, and bedwetting are classic child trauma responses — but effective treatment requires his grandmother's active involvement, because gains won't hold without a stable caregiving environment. TF-CBT (Cohen, Mannarino & Deblinger, 2006) has the strongest evidence for child PTSD, with multiple RCTs showing large effects (d = 0.70-1.0) and is recommended by NICE (NG116), APA, and the VA/DoD. Child-Centered Play Therapy has a solid meta-analytic base (Ray et al., 2015: d = 0.80) primarily for behavioral and emotional problems. PCIT (Eyberg, 1988) has excellent evidence for externalizing behaviors in children ages 2-7, with effects persisting at long-term follow-up. CPP (Lieberman et al., 2005) is the gold standard for young children exposed to violence. At 8, Marcus sits at the intersection of several approaches — a real-world plan might phase them: stabilize the grandmother-Marcus relationship with PCIT, then process trauma with TF-CBT. School coordination is essential — Marcus's teachers are managing his behavior daily, and the therapist who ignores that context is treating half the problem.

Where Approaches Genuinely Disagree

Work with the child or work with the parents?
TF-CBT

The child needs direct trauma processing. Parents are involved but the child does the work.

vs.
Child-Parent Psychotherapy

The relationship IS the treatment. Repair the dyad and the child heals.


6 Formulations

Select 2–3 modalities to compare side by side: