Chronic Illness & Health Identity
Nora, 39, civil engineer
Fictional teaching case
Compare the formulations ↓Presentation
Diagnosed with multiple sclerosis at 26 after an episode of optic neuritis. Three major relapses since, each leaving incremental deficits: fatigue, balance problems, numbness in her left leg. Mother died of MS complications at 58. Now experiencing new symptoms suggesting a fourth relapse while leading the biggest project of her career. Recently told she may need to transition from relapsing-remitting to secondary progressive classification. Says: 'I've been outrunning this thing for thirteen years. I think it's catching up.'
Read the full case history and clinical context
No psychiatric history before MS diagnosis. Married 12 years, one child (age 7). Previously a marathon runner, CrossFit competitor: identity deeply tied to physical capability. Anxiety began after first relapse: constant body scanning, catastrophizing every new sensation (tingling, fatigue, blurred vision). Depressive episode after mother's death two years ago, coincided with her own third relapse. No substance use. One previous therapist focused on 'positive thinking,' which she found dismissive: 'She kept telling me to visualize health. I have lesions on my brain.'
Compare how approaches understand this case
Two approaches to begin with; change them below. These are starting examples, not a clinical ranking.
Choose up to three approaches:
Showing 2 of 6 formulations.
ACT
Nora is fused with the story 'my body is betraying me' and experientially avoiding the grief and terror underneath each new relapse. Her coping strategy, outperform the disease through sheer will and career achievement, is itself avoidance: she controls what she can and suppresses the dread of what she can't. Body scanning is a compulsive attempt to create certainty where none exists. The possible reclassification threatens not just her prognosis but her identity as someone who beats the odds.
Creative hopelessness: the control strategy (outperforming, scanning, pushing through) has organized her life for 13 years. Has it resolved the fear? Defusion from health-related catastrophizing ('That tingling means it's progressing' as a thought, not a diagnosis). Willingness to have fear while living fully. Values clarification: who is Nora if she's not the marathoner, the overachiever, the woman who refuses to slow down?
"You've spent thirteen years outrunning this disease: building your career harder, pushing your body further, monitoring every sensation. And you're exhausted. What if the fear doesn't need to be outrun? What if it just needs to be carried?"
CBT
Health anxiety with a real medical basis: the challenge is that Nora's catastrophizing is sometimes accurate (she does have a progressive neurological condition), so standard cognitive restructuring ('it's probably nothing') is invalidating and clinically inappropriate. The body scanning and symptom monitoring are safety behaviors that maintain anxiety. Negative automatic thoughts: 'Every new sensation means another relapse,' 'I'm going to end up like my mother.'
Modified CBT for health anxiety in medically ill populations. Don't challenge the reality of the disease: challenge the probability estimates and catastrophic interpretations of specific sensations. Behavioral experiments: reduce body-scanning frequency, monitor whether anxiety decreases without the safety behavior. Cognitive restructuring of the mother identification: 'I will deteriorate like her' vs. 'I have the same disease but different treatments, different era of medicine, different body.'
"Your MS is real: I'm not going to tell you it's all in your head. But the body scanning twelve times a day (checking your vision, testing your grip, monitoring your balance) is that keeping you informed, or is it keeping you terrified? Let's test what happens if we set specific check-in times and see what actually changes."
Existential Psychotherapy
Nora is in a confrontation with bodily vulnerability that most people defer until old age. Her mother's death at 58 is not a memory: it's a prophecy she's trying to outrun. Each new relapse, each new deficit, brings the confrontation closer. The 'it's catching up' fatigue is existential exhaustion: the recognition that will and effort cannot override biological reality.
The question isn't whether Nora's disease will progress: it's how she'll live with the knowledge that it might. Explore the mother's death as an existential inheritance, not just a genetic risk factor. What does uncertainty actually mean for how Nora spends her time? The possible reclassification is a loss of a particular kind of hope: grieve it. But it's also a clarification: what matters when the body won't cooperate with your plans?
"Your mother died at 58 from this disease. You're 39. I think that number lives in you every day whether you say it out loud or not. What would it mean to face it directly instead of building another project to outrun it?"
Logotherapy
Nora is facing what Frankl would recognize as unavoidable suffering: a medical reality she cannot change. The question is not how to eliminate the suffering but how to find meaning within it. Her engineering career was an instinctive move toward creating lasting structures: things that endure even when bodies don't. The current crisis is whether meaning can survive further physical limitation.
Explore the meaning Nora has already created: the structures she's designed, the daughter she's raising, the team she leads. In Frankl's terms those are creative values, what she has given the world, and experiential values, what she has received from it. Both are still available to her. But Frankl ranked a third category highest, and it is the one that opens as the others narrow: attitudinal values, the stance a person takes toward a suffering they cannot remove. That is where the reclassification lands. Dereflection: shift attention from the body's limitations to what Nora's presence means to her daughter, her colleagues, the built world she's shaped.
"You said you think the disease is catching up. But I want to point out something: while it's been chasing you, you've been building things. Bridges. A family. A career. Those aren't consolation prizes; those are what you chose when the body changed the rules. What do you want to build next?"
IFS
A powerful Manager part (the Overcomer, the Woman Who Refuses to Slow Down) has been running Nora's life for 13 years. That part built the career, maintained the athletic identity, and kept the fear at bay through relentless achievement. Now the possible reclassification is threatening that part's core strategy. Underneath: an Exile carrying the image of her mother's decline and the terror that she'll leave her daughter the way MS took her own mother.
The Overcomer part deserves enormous respect: it has kept Nora functional and fighting for 13 years. But it's running out of road. Gently explore what it's protecting: the terrified Exile who watched her mother deteriorate and knows the same thing could happen to her. The body-scanning Manager is trying to prevent surprise: it never wants to be caught off guard the way each relapse has ambushed her. Neither Manager will stand down on Nora's instruction, since she has no leverage over them they do not already have over her. What shifts it is Self: enough calm and curiosity in Nora to turn toward the Exile without dread, and to let her unburden the certainty that she is watching her own future in her mother's decline.
"The part of you that keeps pushing (the part that runs the projects, that refuses to slow down), that part has been extraordinary. But I think it's tired. And I think there's something underneath it that's been waiting a long time to be heard."
Narrative Therapy
Nora's identity narrative (athlete, achiever, someone who refuses to be limited) has been progressively thinned by each relapse. The disease keeps rewriting her story. The engineering career was a narrative she authored with agency and precision. Now the possible reclassification threatens to make her a passive character in her own story: defined by prognosis rather than ambition.
Externalize the disease narrative: how has MS tried to define Nora? What has it taken? What has it failed to take? Find unique outcomes: the career she built, the motherhood she chose, the project she's leading now: all authored in the face of the disease. Re-author: what does strength look like when the body changes the terms? The marathon identity isn't the only story of power she has.
"MS has been rewriting your story for thirteen years. It took the marathons, it's working on your balance. But you made moves it didn't predict: you built a career, you became a mother, you're leading the biggest project of your life right now. What else can you author that the disease can't edit?"
Where Approaches Genuinely Disagree
Acceptance here means willingness to feel the grief, not resignation to the prognosis. Defuse from the 'healthy person' identity and move toward what matters now, with the mourning still in progress.
Grief for the lost self needs to be fully mourned before a new identity can form.
Philosophical Lenses
These are not treatment plans. They are ways of seeing — philosophical perspectives that illuminate aspects of this case that clinical modalities may not address directly.
Nora's MS has progressively reorganized her body schema: the pre-reflective map through which she moves in the world. Each relapse leaves 'incremental deficits' that are not just medical facts but phenomenological transformations: the fatigue is not tiredness but a new way of inhabiting time; the balance problems are not a malfunction but a reorganization of the body's relationship to space; the numbness in her left leg is not an absence of sensation but a different mode of sensing. Merleau-Ponty would insist that Nora does not 'have' a body that happens to be ill. She is her body, and her body is becoming someone new with each relapse. The grief she feels is not about losing function. It is about losing the person she was, as experienced from the inside.
Nora's MS confronts her with a version of the absurd that Camus explored in The Myth of Sisyphus: the collision between the human need for coherence and a body that refuses to provide it. She was diagnosed at 26, she has had three major relapses, and she knows there will be more. The disease has no logic she can master, no timeline she can plan around. Yet she continues: meeting with clients, reviewing plans, living as if the future is stable when she knows it is not. Camus would recognize this as the absurd hero's stance: full awareness of the situation, refusal to be consoled by false hope, and continued engagement anyway. The question is not whether Nora can 'accept' her illness. It is whether she can live fully inside the contradiction of a body that is both hers and beyond her control.
Butler's work on precarity, from Precarious Life onward, illuminates Nora's situation. Precarity is not just economic vulnerability: it is the unequal distribution of bodily exposure to harm. Nora's MS has made her precarious in a way that is invisible to most people around her: she looks fine, she functions, she engineers. But her body is exposed to a future that able-bodied people are permitted to ignore. Her mother had MS too: the intergenerational dimension is not just genetic but political. Two women's lives shaped by a disease that the healthcare system manages but does not cure, that the workplace accommodates grudgingly, that the social world treats as individual misfortune rather than shared vulnerability. Butler would ask what it would mean for Nora to grieve not just her losses but the social conditions that make chronic illness a private problem rather than a collective one.
Sources & Method
This is a composite fictional case — no real client is depicted. Formulations represent how each modality would typically conceptualize and approach a case with this presentation, based on published clinical literature and training materials. Each formulation draws on the modality's own theoretical framework, key texts, and clinical principles as documented on its modality page. Full source citations for every modality are available on the Sources page.