PTSD & Acute Trauma

Trauma- and Stressor-Related Disorders (DSM-5-TR)

Intrusions, avoidance, negative cognitions/mood, and hyperarousal following exposure to a traumatic event. Includes PTSD and acute stress disorder. Best-studied area of psychotherapy — multiple treatments have strong evidence.

Prevalence: ~6% lifetime; higher in combat veterans, assault survivors

Clinical Picture

PTSD treatment has more high-quality evidence behind it than almost any other condition in psychotherapy research. The three treatments with the strongest evidence — CPT, Prolonged Exposure, and EMDR — work through different mechanisms but converge on the same principle: the traumatic memory must be accessed and processed rather than avoided. Where they diverge is in how processing happens. PE uses repeated narrative exposure. CPT works through written accounts and cognitive restructuring of 'stuck points.' EMDR uses bilateral stimulation during trauma reprocessing. The clinical question isn't which is 'best' in the abstract but which fits this client's presentation, tolerance for distress, and cognitive style.

Treatment Considerations

For single-incident adult trauma with clear PTSD symptoms, any of the guideline-recommended treatments is a reasonable starting point. The choice often depends on practical factors: PE requires homework (daily listening to session recordings); CPT requires written work; EMDR requires less between-session work but demands the client's capacity to tolerate dual attention. For clients with significant dissociation, avoidance, or complex trauma histories, a stabilization phase may be necessary before trauma processing begins. The somatic and attachment-focused approaches listed in the emerging evidence tier may be more appropriate as primary treatments for developmental or complex trauma.


53 Therapeutic Approaches

Sorted by evidence tier: guideline-recommended first, then RCT-supported, then emerging/limited evidence.

Guideline-Recommended (10)
Cognitive-Behavioral
CBT
Aaron Beck · 1964
Effect: g = 0.62
~50% remission
APA Div 12: Strong/Very Strong for multiple disorders. NICE: recommended for depression, all anxiety…
Attachment
Child-Parent Psychotherapy
Alicia Lieberman · 1995
California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse: highest rating (1); SAMHSA NREPP listed
Cognitive-Behavioral
CPT
Patricia Resick · 1992
Effect: d = 0.83
~50-65% remission
VA/DoD 2023: Recommended (strong). APA: Strongly recommended
Trauma-Focused
EMDR
Francine Shapiro · 1989
Effect: g = 0.66
~55-70% no longer meet PTSD criteria
VA/DoD 2023: Recommended (strong). WHO: recommended. NICE: recommended. APA: Conditionally recommend…
Cognitive-Behavioral
Imagery Rehearsal Therapy
Barry Krakow · 1995
VA/DoD: strongly recommended for nightmare disorder. AASM: recommended. APA Div 12: well-established…
Trauma-Focused
Narrative Exposure Therapy
Schauer / Neuner / Elbert · 2004
Effect: d = 0.76
~55-70% no longer meet criteria
WHO: mentioned for PTSD in conflict settings
Cognitive-Behavioral
Prolonged Exposure
Edna Foa · 1986
Effect: d = 1.08
~60-70% remission
VA/DoD 2023: Recommended (strong). NICE: recommended. APA: Strongly recommended. WHO: recommended
Cognitive-Behavioral
STAIR
Marylene Cloitre · 2002
Effect: d = 0.76 vs active control
~55-65% improvement in cPTSD
Referenced in complex PTSD treatment guidelines
Cognitive-Behavioral
TF-CBT
Cohen / Mannarino / Deblinger · 2006
Effect: d = 0.83
~60-70% remission
NICE: recommended for child PTSD. APA: recommended. SAMHSA: listed
Trauma-Focused
Written Exposure Therapy
Sloan / Marx · 2019
Effect: Non-inferior to CPT
~50-60% no longer meet criteria
VA/DoD 2023: Suggested (weak for) PTSD
RCT-Supported (30)
Trauma-Focused
Accelerated Resolution Therapy
Laney Rosenzweig · 2008
Effect: d = 1.05 (military sample)
~60-75% significant improvement
Trauma-Focused
Adaptive Disclosure
Brett Litz & colleagues · 2017
Effect: d = 0.65 for moral injury
~45-55%; especially moral injury
Somatic
Biofeedback
Various (Sterman / Schwartz / Green) · 1960
Trauma-Focused
Brainspotting
David Grand · 2003
Effect: d = 0.89 (single RCT)
~60-70% significant improvement
Cognitive-Behavioral
CBT-I
Spielman / Perlis · 1987
Family Systems
Circle of Security
Glen Cooper / Kent Hoffman / Bert Powell · 1998
Integrative
EFT Tapping
Gary Craig · 1995
Effect: d = 2.96
~60-90% no longer meet criteria
Social Justice
Feminist Therapy
Various (Lerman, Brown, Worell, Enns) · 1970
Trauma-Focused
Flash Technique
Philip Manfield · 2016
Effect: Preliminary RCT positive
Rapid SUD reduction in sessions
Cognitive-Behavioral
iCBT
Various (Andersson / Titov) · 2000
Family Systems
IFS
Richard Schwartz · 1995
Effect: d = 0.94 (single RCT)
~50-60% no longer meet criteria
Psychedelic
KAP
Various (Wolfson, Bennett) · 2010
Trauma-Focused
Lifespan Integration
Peggy Pace · 2003
Effect: Preliminary; limited RCT data
Case series suggest rapid reduction
Psychedelic
MDMA-Assisted Therapy
MAPS / Mithoefer · 2021
Effect: d = 0.91
~67% no longer met PTSD criteria
Humanistic
Play Therapy
Virginia Axline · 1947
Cognitive-Behavioral
Seeking Safety
Lisa Najavits · 2002
Somatic
Sensorimotor Psychotherapy
Pat Ogden · 1981
Effect: Preliminary; limited RCTs
Case series show body-based improvement
Somatic
Somatic Experiencing
Peter Levine · 1997
Effect: d = 0.94 (Brom et al.)
~44% remission
Trauma-Focused
Structural Dissociation
Onno van der Hart, Ellert Nijenhuis, Kathy Steele · 2006
Cognitive-Behavioral
Acceptance-Based Behavior Therapy
Lizabeth Roemer / Susan Orsillo · 2002
Somatic
Advanced Integrative Therapy
Asha Clinton · 2002
Integrative
Common Factors / Contextual Model
Bruce Wampold / Saul Rosenzweig · 1936
Expressive
Dance/Movement Therapy
Marian Chace · 1942
Psychedelic
EMBARK
Brennan / Belser · 2022
Integrative
Ketamine-Assisted EMDR™ (KA-EMDR)
Danielle Ciccone & Michele Topel · 2024
Cognitive-Behavioral
Metacognitive Therapy
Adrian Wells · 2009
Somatic
Neurofeedback
Barry Sterman / Joel Lubar · 1968
Crisis
Psychological First Aid
National Child Traumatic Stress Network / NCTSN · 2006
Expressive
Sandtray Therapy
Dora Kalff (Jungian) / Various · 1956
Somatic
Trauma-Sensitive Yoga
David Emerson / van der Kolk · 2005

Related Clinical Vignettes


Sources & References

Prevalence data from NIMH, WHO, and DSM-5-TR field trial publications. Evidence tiers reflect guideline status (APA, NICE, VA/DoD, WHO) and meta-analytic findings as of early 2025. Individual modality citations are listed on each modality page. Full bibliography available on the Sources page.

Ogden et al., 2006 (2006) — cited for Sensorimotor Psychotherapy
Powers et al., 2010 (2010) — cited for Prolonged Exposure
Cloitre et al., 2010 (2010) — cited for STAIR
Pace, 2012 (2012) — cited for Lifespan Integration
Kip et al., 2013 (2013) — cited for Accelerated Resolution Therapy
Cusack et al., 2016 (2016) — cited for CPT
Hildebrand et al., 2017 (2017) — cited for Brainspotting
Manfield et al., 2017 (2017) — cited for Flash Technique
Brom et al., 2017 (2017) — cited for Somatic Experiencing
Sloan et al., 2018 (2018) — cited for Written Exposure Therapy
Church et al., 2018 (2018) — cited for EFT Tapping
Lely et al., 2019 (2019) — cited for Narrative Exposure Therapy
Mavranezouli et al., 2020 (2020) — cited for TF-CBT
Mitchell et al., 2021 (2021) — cited for MDMA-Assisted Therapy
Litz et al., 2021 (2021) — cited for Adaptive Disclosure
Hodgdon et al., 2022 (2022) — cited for IFS
Chen et al., 2014; VA/DoD 2023 (2023) — cited for EMDR