Depression & Mood Disorders

Depressive Disorders / Bipolar Disorders (DSM-5-TR)

Persistent low mood, loss of interest, fatigue, sleep/appetite disruption, and cognitive changes. Includes major depressive disorder, persistent depressive disorder (dysthymia), bipolar depression, and perinatal mood disorders. One of the most common reasons people seek therapy.

Prevalence: ~8% of US adults in any given year; ~20% lifetime

Clinical Picture

Depression is not one thing. The flat, leaden immobility of melancholic depression is neurobiologically and experientially different from the agitated, ruminative quality of anxious depression or the irritable emptiness of what's sometimes called 'male-type' depression. Treatment selection depends on which depression you're actually looking at. Behavioral activation works well for the withdrawal-and-avoidance pattern. Cognitive restructuring targets the ruminative loop. Psychodynamic approaches may be essential when depression is rooted in unprocessed grief, chronic self-attack, or relational templates established in childhood. Somatic approaches become relevant when the body itself seems to carry the depression — when the client can articulate no thoughts but reports heaviness, constriction, or numbness.

Treatment Considerations

For mild-to-moderate depression, most evidence-based approaches show comparable outcomes — the therapeutic alliance matters more than the specific modality. For severe or treatment-resistant depression, combined approaches (therapy plus medication) consistently outperform either alone. When depression co-occurs with trauma history, treating the depression alone often fails because the depressive symptoms are maintained by unresolved traumatic material. The vignettes on this site illustrate how different modalities formulate the same depressive presentation in genuinely different ways.


81 Therapeutic Approaches

Sorted by evidence tier: guideline-recommended first, then RCT-supported, then emerging/limited evidence.

Guideline-Recommended (14)
Cognitive-Behavioral
ACT
Steven Hayes · 1999
Effect: g = 0.56
~40-55% response
APA Div 12: listed for chronic pain, depression
Cognitive-Behavioral
Behavioral Activation
Lewinsohn / Martell · 1974
Effect: g = 0.74
~50-60% response
NICE: recommended for depression. APA Div 12: Strong Research Support
Integrative
CBASP
James McCullough · 2000
NICE (2022): Recommended for chronic depression
Cognitive-Behavioral
CBT
Aaron Beck · 1964
Effect: g = 0.71
~50-60% response
APA Div 12: Strong/Very Strong for multiple disorders. NICE: recommended for depression, all anxiety…
Humanistic
Emotion-Focused Therapy
Leslie Greenberg · 1990
Effect: d = 0.70
~50-65% response
APA Div 12: Strong Research Support for depression
Cognitive-Behavioral
iCBT
Various (Andersson / Titov) · 2000
NICE: recommended for depression and anxiety (stepped care). Australian NHMRC: recommended. Growing …
Integrative
IPT
Klerman / Weissman · 1984
Effect: d = 0.63
~50-60% response
NICE: recommended for depression. APA: Strong. WHO: recommended
Psychedelic
KAP
Various (Wolfson, Bennett) · 2010
Effect: d = 0.80-1.20 (varies by study)
~50-70% response at 24h (single dose)
FDA: esketamine (Spravato) approved for TRD (2019)
Cognitive-Behavioral
MBCT
Segal / Williams / Teasdale · 2002
Effect: HR = 0.69 vs TAU
~30-40% additional relapse prevention
NICE: recommended for recurrent depression. APA Div 12: Strong Research Support
Humanistic
Person-Centered Therapy
Carl Rogers · 1951
Effect: d = 0.55
~45-55% response
NICE: counselling recommended for mild-moderate depression
Cognitive-Behavioral
Problem-Solving Therapy
D'Zurilla / Nezu · 1971
Effect: d = 0.83
~50-60% response
APA Div 12: listed. NICE: mentioned for depression
Psychedelic
Psilocybin-Assisted Therapy
Griffiths / Carhart-Harris · 2016
Effect: d = 1.56 (2 doses)
~54-71% response at 4 weeks
FDA: Breakthrough Therapy designation for TRD and MDD
Psychoanalytic
Psychoanalysis
Sigmund Freud · 1895
Effect: d = 0.78
~50-60% response in long-term
NICE: long-term PDT considered for complex depression
Psychoanalytic
Short-Term Psychodynamic
Davanloo / Sifneos / Malan · 1968
Effect: d = 0.58
~45-55% response
NICE: recommended for depression
RCT-Supported (42)
Trauma-Focused
Accelerated Resolution Therapy
Laney Rosenzweig · 2008
Psychoanalytic
AEDP
Diana Fosha · 2000
Effect: Preliminary; no large RCT
Case series show rapid affect shifts
Cognitive-Behavioral
Behavioral Couples Therapy
Neil Jacobson / Andrew Christensen · 1979
Somatic
Biofeedback
Various (Sterman / Schwartz / Green) · 1960
Cognitive-Behavioral
CBT-I
Spielman / Perlis · 1987
Family Systems
Circle of Security
Glen Cooper / Kent Hoffman / Bert Powell · 1998
Cognitive-Behavioral
Compassion-Focused Therapy
Paul Gilbert · 2005
Effect: g = 0.64
~45-55% response
Expressive
Dance/Movement Therapy
Marian Chace · 1942
Effect: d = 0.68
Cognitive-Behavioral
DBT
Marsha Linehan · 1993
Trauma-Focused
EMDR
Francine Shapiro · 1989
Cognitive-Behavioral
Imagery Rehearsal Therapy
Barry Krakow · 1995
Humanistic
Interpersonal Process Group Therapy
Irvin Yalom · 1970
Psychoanalytic
ISTDP
Habib Davanloo · 1980
Effect: d = 0.97
~55-65% response
Humanistic
Life Review Therapy
Robert Butler · 1963
Expressive
Music Therapy
Nordoff / Robbins · 1950
Effect: SMD = -0.98
~40-50% response
Postmodern
Narrative Therapy
Michael White / David Epston · 1990
Effect: Limited RCT data
Qualitative evidence strong
Cognitive-Behavioral
REBT
Albert Ellis · 1955
Psychoanalytic
Relational Psychoanalysis
Stephen Mitchell / Lewis Aron · 1988
Effect: d = 0.78
~50-60% for long-term psychodynamic
Cognitive-Behavioral
Rumination-Focused CBT
Edward Watkins · 2016
Effect: d = 0.70-1.10
~50-65% response
Cognitive-Behavioral
Schema Therapy
Jeffrey Young · 1990
Postmodern
SFBT
de Shazer / Insoo Kim Berg · 1985
Effect: d = 0.57
~45-55% response
Psychoanalytic
Supportive Psychotherapy
Various (Rockland, Winston) · 1950
Effect: d = 0.58
~40-50% response
Cognitive-Behavioral
Acceptance-Based Behavior Therapy
Lizabeth Roemer / Susan Orsillo · 2002
Somatic
Advanced Integrative Therapy
Asha Clinton · 2002
Psychoanalytic
Analytical Psychology
Carl Jung · 1913
Integrative
Common Factors / Contextual Model
Bruce Wampold / Saul Rosenzweig · 1936
Cognitive-Behavioral
Compassionate Mind Training
Paul Gilbert · 2005
Integrative
EFT Tapping
Gary Craig · 1995
Psychedelic
EMBARK
Brennan / Belser · 2022
Integrative
Emotion Regulation Therapy
Douglas Mennin & David Fresco · 2014
Attachment
Emotionally Focused Individual Therapy
Sue Johnson / Leslie Greenberg (adapted) · 2012
Cognitive-Behavioral
Functional Analytic Psychotherapy
Robert Kohlenberg / Mavis Tsai · 1991
Family Systems
IFS
Richard Schwartz · 1995
Integrative
MBSR
Jon Kabat-Zinn · 1979
Cognitive-Behavioral
Metacognitive Therapy
Adrian Wells · 2009
Somatic
Neurofeedback
Barry Sterman / Joel Lubar · 1968
Integrative
Pluralistic Therapy
Mick Cooper / John McLeod · 2011
Humanistic
Positive Psychotherapy
Nossrat Peseschkian · 1977
Humanistic
Process Group Therapy
Irvin Yalom · 1970
Cognitive-Behavioral
RO-DBT
Thomas Lynch · 2018
Somatic
Trauma-Sensitive Yoga
David Emerson / van der Kolk · 2005
Cognitive-Behavioral
Unified Protocol
David Barlow · 2011
Emerging / Limited Evidence (25)
Psychoanalytic
Adlerian Therapy
Alfred Adler · 1912
Integrative
Advanced Integrative Therapy (AIT)
Asha Clinton · 2002
Trauma-Focused
Attachment-Focused EMDR
Laurel Parnell · 2013
Somatic
Bioenergetic Analysis
Alexander Lowen / Wilhelm Reich · 1956
Contemplative
Buddhist Psychology / Contemplative Psychotherapy
Chögyam Trungpa / Jack Kornfield / Mark Epstein · 1974
Integrative
Coherence Therapy
Ecker / Hulley · 1996
Humanistic
Collaborative Therapy
Harlene Anderson / Harold Goolishian · 1988
Family Systems
Contextual Therapy
Ivan Boszormenyi-Nagy · 1973
Somatic
Craniosacral Therapy
John Upledger · 1970
Existential
Daseinsanalysis
Boss / Binswanger · 1942
Existential
Existential Psychotherapy
Rollo May / Irvin Yalom · 1958
Humanistic
Gestalt Therapy
Fritz & Laura Perls · 1951
Psychedelic
Holotropic Breathwork
Stanislav Grof / Christina Grof · 1976
Psychoanalytic
Lacanian Psychoanalysis
Jacques Lacan · 1953
Trauma-Focused
Lifespan Integration
Peggy Pace · 2003
Existential
Logotherapy
Viktor Frankl · 1946
Integrative
Multimodal Therapy
Arnold Lazarus · 1976
Contemplative
Naikan Therapy
Ishin Yoshimoto · 1940
Integrative
NLP
Richard Bandler & John Grinder · 1975
Somatic
Primal Therapy
Arthur Janov · 1970
Psychedelic
PSIP
Saj Razvi · 2016
Psychedelic
Psychedelic Harm Reduction & Integration (PHRI)
Various (Gorman, Nielson, Gael) · 2015
Cognitive-Behavioral
Reality Therapy / Choice Theory
William Glasser · 1965
Social Justice
Relational-Cultural Therapy
Jean Baker Miller / Judith Jordan · 1976
Integrative
Transactional Analysis
Eric Berne · 1958

Related Clinical Vignettes


Sources & References

Prevalence data from NIMH, WHO, and DSM-5-TR field trial publications. Evidence tiers reflect guideline status (APA, NICE, VA/DoD, WHO) and meta-analytic findings as of early 2025. Individual modality citations are listed on each modality page. Full bibliography available on the Sources page.

White & Epston, 1990 (1990) — cited for Narrative Therapy
Fosha, 2000 (2000) — cited for AEDP
Leichsenring & Rabung, 2008 (2008) — cited for Psychoanalysis
Cuijpers et al., 2011 (2011) — cited for IPT
Watkins et al., 2011 (2011) — cited for Rumination-Focused CBT
Elliott et al., 2013 (2013) — cited for Emotion-Focused Therapy
Gingerich & Peterson, 2013 (2013) — cited for SFBT
Ekers et al., 2014 (2014) — cited for Behavioral Activation
Koch et al., 2014 (2014) — cited for Dance/Movement Therapy
Driessen et al., 2015 (2015) — cited for Short-Term Psychodynamic
A-Tjak et al., 2015 (2015) — cited for ACT
Kuyken et al., 2016 (2016) — cited for MBCT
Kishimoto et al., 2016 (2016) — cited for KAP
Town et al., 2017 (2017) — cited for ISTDP
Kirby et al., 2017 (2017) — cited for Compassion-Focused Therapy
Aalbers et al., 2017 (Cochrane) (2017) — cited for Music Therapy
Cuijpers et al., 2018 (2018) — cited for Problem-Solving Therapy
Cuijpers et al., 2019 (2019) — cited for CBT
Davis et al., 2021; Goodwin et al., 2022 (2022) — cited for Psilocybin-Assisted Therapy
Leichsenring et al., 2023 (2023) — cited for Relational Psychoanalysis